Follow @deeplyconcernedmembers for updates

NEWS · 10 NOVEMBER 2026

Mowbray Muslim Cemetery: Why the Board's AGM Postponement Application to Court Was Opposed

This website was created ahead of the August 2026 elections to urge members to vote for candidates who we knew were committed to holding an AGM, with financial statements, in October, as the Constitution requires. As an AGM is what gives the community a voice. Once that AGM was held and the Maqbarah was firmly back in the community's hands, the website was to close, its purpose being served.

Unfortunately, as this website warned, members of the previous Board returned to office, and then the Board went to court to postpone the AGM that was due in October 2026, last month.

The public statement below sets out what happened in court on 29 October and why a concerned member opposed the delay. He was not entirely successful, but the court set 14 March 2027 as the latest date for the AGM, instead of the 30 May the Board had asked for.

PUBLIC STATEMENT

Case No. 2025-238197

Date of Release: 10 November 2026

Issued by: Dr Bassier, the member cited as a respondent in the Board’s postponement application. He is referred to below in the third person as “the concerned member”, as he acted on behalf of the community. The person who deposed for the Board was the chair.

On 29 October 2026, the Board went to court on an urgent basis, at considerable legal cost, to postpone the AGM. It cited only two respondents: the concerned member (Dr Bassier) and the Independent Panel. Since the matter was going to court anyway, the concerned member opposed it.

He was dismayed to be cited alone with the Panel. In his answering affidavit, he asked: why him alone, when he is just one of more than 1,500 members? Why were the others not informed or given a chance to be heard? He reluctantly opposed the application, incurring personal legal costs, because the wider membership needed to be represented and another postponement should not go unchallenged. He also asked for a personal costs order against the Board members who brought the application, so as to avoid burial money being used.

Why the concerned member opposed

  • The Constitution requires the AGM to be held in October, making 31 October the latest date. The Board did not dispute this in court, in fact, that is the very reason they approached the court, even though it had known of the deadline for months.
  • Concerned members have called for an AGM and accountability since 2015. Before the August 2026 elections, deeplyconcernedmembers.co.za warned: “Our concern is that, if members of the previous Board are elected again, AGMs may once again be avoided through various reasons or excuses.” That concern has now materialised, leaving the concerned member no option but to oppose so that the AGM could proceed on schedule.
  • There was no reason to delay. The elections had been held at the SGM in August and the Board had previously presented the financials as sorted. The AGM was simply a chance for the community to engage on matters affecting the cemetery.

The Board’s reasons, and why they do not stand up

Reason 1: Outstanding financial statements for 2025 and 2026

  • The 2025 financial statements should have been ready in August last year already, as the financial year ends February 2025.
  • In April 2026, when questions were raised about the Association’s finances, the Board provided a statement saying its affairs had been audited up to February 2024. Its accuracy was questioned because it described the Association as an NPO, which it is not.
  • In the August court proceedings on the bank statements, the Board relied on that same statement to argue that up-to-date bank statements were unnecessary. Yet having treated the 2024 financials as sufficient in August, the Board suddenly made the 2025 and 2026 financial statements a reason to postpone the AGM in October, although they had not been an issue just months earlier. Nor is requiring the 2026 financials a reason to postpone this AGM.
  • Despite the member making a request last week to view the alleged audited financial statements, and despite the Association being waqf property, which demands absolute transparency, the Board has still not acceded to his request.

Reason 2: The previous Board is to blame for unresolved problems

  • In the Chair’s postponement affidavit, he cites significant problems as a reason for delay. Yet he chaired the Board that oversaw those problems for six consecutive years, having served on it for nearly seven.
  • Because the matter was brought urgently, it came before a judge unfamiliar with the case, so it had to be clarified that this is not a new Board. It is essentially a continuation of the previous one: the current Chair, Vice Chair, Assistant Treasurer and one other member all served on the previous Board for years, joined by newly added members.

Reason 3: Concern about membership eligibility at the AGM

  • The Board did not go to court to challenge the elections or the membership process behind them. Yet it now cites doubts about who is a member as a reason to delay, when the main criterion for membership is that the person is Muslim. If those who voted the Board in are not really members, is the Board’s own election in doubt? The Board has not suggested that. It went to court only to postpone the community’s AGM.
  • The Court appointed Panel was tasked with verifying and vetting the membership, the around 1600 members, which was just that the person is of a certain age and Muslim, and that process was completed over 2 months ago and digitised, culminating in the elections at the SGM. So the Board delayed this important AGM just to double check everyone on the list is of a certain age?
  • The Board never said there would be voting for positions at the October AGM, so why raise voting as a concern in its affidavit? The concern is moot and sounds like an excuse.

Reason 4: Practical arrangements and cost

  • The Board said it was a “new” Board, and needed time. Yet the election results were announced on 28 August 2026, over two months before the 29 October application. That was ample time to prepare, so there was no reason to delay.
  • The Board cited the cost of an AGM, yet mosques and Muslim NGOs hold AGMs all the time. The legal fees for this urgent application likely far exceeded the cost of an AGM.

The outcome of the court proceedings

The Board sought a postponement until 30 May 2027. In the concerned member’s affidavit (paras 50 and 56), he said the AGM should proceed in October or, failing that, by the end of November 2026 at the very latest.

The Board waited until 29 October, two days before the deadline, to apply. That left the court in an impossible position. Even if it had refused, the Constitution requires seven days’ notice for an AGM, so the AGM could not lawfully have been held by 31 October anyway. The Association would have been in breach of its Constitution either way. The court therefore had to postpone, and the only real question was when.

The court therefore set 14 March 2027 as the latest date for the AGM, a compromise considerably earlier than the Board wanted. Importantly, it never validated the Board’s resolution. In choosing March, the court took into account the Board’s argument that December and January were impractical due to the holidays.

A media report initially described the March date as ‘by agreement’. The concerned member did not agree and corrected it, as the community should not be seen as accepting further delay. The court order was subsequently corrected on 3 November 2026 to remove the words ‘by agreement between the parties’. There is also concern that, as March approaches, the Board will again cite outstanding financial statements, push for 30 May, and argue the 2027 statements are not ready, so the delay continues.

A pattern of avoiding accountability

In September 2021, a member emailed the chairman to remind him about the AGM, which was due in October. This followed the January 2021 incident in which a mayet was initially refused burial because, in a newsletter on 30 November 2020 on which the chair is cited, he had announced an earlier closing time for the Maqbarah, with entry afterwards only on payment of an overtime fee. That made an AGM all the more important, so the community could know what was happening with the finances. The Board, led by him since November 2020 and still today, cited COVID-19 as the reason to postpone the AGM.

In September 2026, exactly five years later, and months after the court declared the planned mortuary unlawful, and with the finances questioned in the bank statements application, the same chair was asked through the media about the AGM due in October. Rather than promising one, he said they were still deliberating as the Treasurer and Secretary were overseas and he was also travelling. A deadline of 12 October was given, but no feedback followed. Instead came the urgent court application on 29 October.

This is not a new Board finding its feet. It is largely the same leadership under the same chairperson, giving a different reason each time an AGM was due: COVID-19, financials, membership, travel, constitution.

There is, however, a silver lining. Although the majority of the Board voted to postpone, three of the new Board members refused to postpone accountability. They kept to the amanah and voted against postponement, as there was again, no legal or practical basis for a delay. The Maqbarah and its money belong to the community. This is burial money, paid by families at their most vulnerable, and the Board must account to the community for it. That is what an AGM is for. These three did what honourable custodians do: they stood with the community on principle, even when it meant standing apart from their own Board.

Shukran

Dr Bassier

The concerned member and respondent

10 November 2026